The Bennion Family Monument in Rush Valley is Fit Again

by John Bennion

On May 13, 2023, Mark Bennion and I worked on repairing the family monument in Bennion Canyon, Rush Valley.  Mark provided the skilled masonry and cement labor, and I did the unskilled grunt work. Mark and I are first cousins and descendants of John Bennion and Esther Anne Birch, Israel and Jeanette, Glynn and Lucile, and respectively George and Joye and Colin and Sergene.

Mark on the left; John on the right.

We removed loose stones and reseated them with new grout. The top stone was also loose, so we reseated it. Then we poured new cement around the base, shoring it up. We plan to contour the ground above the monument so spring runoff will not erode under the monument and to build a fence to keep cattle from rubbing against the stones. It should last another ninety years.

The monument was dedicated as part of a Bennion family reunion in Vernon, Utah, held on July 24, 1933. After speeches, lunch, and sporting activities in the Vernon Ward meeting house, the group drove south to the mouth of Bennion Canyon, where Israel Bennion dedicated the monument.  

Left to right: Israel Bennion, Elizabeth Harker Bennion, Emma Bennion Linsay, Rebecca Ann Bennion Sharp. In the background can be seen David Bennion.

To read a brochure about the reunion and dedication see the Bennion Family Association website (bennion.org). On the landing page, click on “Archives” and then “Places.”

The owner of the property where the monument stands, Jim Ekker, has been generous to work with us. He put in a gate so people can easily get access to the monument. On the Bennion website is a Google map that can guide those interested in visiting the monument and other Bennion family sites in the south end of Rush Valley.  On the landing page, click on “Archives” and then “Places.”

Family History: Remembering Mervyn S. Bennion and the USS Bennion

By Richard and John E. Bennion, (twins and first cousins once removed from Mervyn S. Bennion)

 

While on summer vacation in Southern California in the early 1960’s, we procured a model kit from a local hobby store and assembled a replica of the USS Bennion DD62, a destroyer named after Mervyn Sharp Bennion, who was captain of the USS West Virginia and recipient of the Congressional Medal of Honor.

Model kit like the one made by Richard and John Bennion.

 

When we were pre-teenagers in the late 1950’s, we had started to learn about World War II and its impact on our family. Our father, Donald Clark Bennion, was drafted into the US Army in 1942 but was somewhat miraculously discharged a few months later so that he could go work for US Steel in the Los Angeles area. His brother (our uncle) Herald Clark Bennion, served in the US Navy and was killed in the Pacific theater at Guadalcanal, Solomon Islands, in 1943. Our father felt that perhaps he was partly responsible for his brother Herald’s death, that Herald died instead of him. As a result, our father helped support his widow financially for several years after the war, and we remember meeting her. At evening family prayer, we always mentioned Aunt Marjorie (Herald's widow). She died in 1988, and this year we visited the SLC Cemetery and found her grave. Interestingly, next to her grave is a gravestone memorial for Herald (even though his remains were never found and he is listed on Family Search as "buried at sea."  

 

As we were learning these stories about our father and uncle, we also learned about Capt. Mervyn S. Bennion, commander of the battleship USS West Virginia, who was killed at Pearl Harbor on 7 December 1941 and was posthumously awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor. Mervyn was our father’s first cousin—same grandfather, different grandmother in a plural marriage.

 

Because we received the model and put it together while we were in elementary school, we didn’t appreciate the full context of the sacrifice given by those who died in World War II. However, we were very impressed by the model and put it together carefully. We were very proud to have a ship named after our relative. Through the years we have learned about Mervyn’s heroism—his abdomen was ripped open by a piece of shrapnel from a bomb explosion on the nearby USS Tennessee, but he refused treatment. He used one arm to hold his intestines inside as much as possible, and continued to effectively command the ship for the next four hours until he died. The USS West Virginia was the only ship that was battle-ready and shot down more Japanese planes than any other ship in Pearl Harbor, thanks to Mervyn’s leadership while mortally wounded. We proudly displayed the model for many years at our vacation home on Balboa Island and repeated his story to any of our friends willing to listen. We would love to have the model and put it together again.

 

The USS Bennion was a Fletcher Class Destroyer. It was launched on 4 July 1943 at Boston Navy Yard and christened by Captain Bennion's widow, Annie Louise Clark Bennion, daughter of J. Ruben Clark, Jr. The USS Bennion was commissioned the following December, and was involved in several battles in the Pacific Theater of WWII.  Most notably, the Bennion received a Presidential Citation and 8 Battle Stars for her outstanding performance in the Battle of Suriago Strait where she assisted in the sinking of the Japanese battleship Yamashiro.

USS Bennion DD62, a Fletcher Class Destroyer named after Mervyn Sharp Bennion. It was launched on 4 July 1943.

The Presidential Unit Citation, awarded by James Forrestal, Secretary of the Navy, reads,

For extraordinary heroism in action as a Fighter Direction ship on Radar Picket duty during the Okinawa Campaign, April 1, to June 1, 1945. A natural and frequent target of the heavy Japanese aerial attack while occupying advanced and isolated stations, the U.S.S. BENNION defeated all efforts of enemy Kamikaze and dive-bombing planes to destroy her. Constantly vigilant and ready for battle day and night, she sent out early air warnings, provided fighter direction and, with her own fierce gun fire downed thirteen hostile planes, shared the destruction of others and routed many more; and she rendered valiant service in preventing the Japanese from striking in force the Naval Forces off the Okinawa Beachhead. A valiant fighting ship, the BENNION, her officers and her men withstood the stress and perils of vital Radar Picket duty, achieving a gallant combat record which attests the teamwork, courage and skill of her entire company and enhances the finest traditions of the United States Naval Service. 

The Bennion returned to Puget Sound Navy Yard on 27 October 1945 and went out of commission in reserve at Long Beach, Calif., 20 June 1946.

 

A few years ago we had a family reunion and we all wore T-shirts commemorating the USS Bennion. Over the years, each of us has visited Pearl Harbor and heard the story of Mervyn’s heroism.  We have also visited his grave in the Salt Lake City Cemetery. We were, and still are, proud to be his relatives. 

Richard Bennion wearing the T-shirt designed for a family reunion.

 

(For more information about Mervyn S. Bennion, go to his name in this website: Archives/People/Mervyn S. Bennion.)

Captain Mervyn S.. Bennion

This article was added by John Schlatter to Fold3 on September 23, 2020. The original can be found at Together We Served.

Captain Mervyn Sharp Bennion, U.S. Navy, grew up on a cattle ranch in rural Utah, earned an appointment to the U.S. Naval Academy, served with distinction for 31 years, and died a hero while commanding the USS West Virginia during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor December 7, 1941. For his actions that day he was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor, our nation’s highest military award.

When the Japanese bombers struck Pearl Harbor just before 8 a.m. that Sunday morning, the West Virginia was hit by torpedoes and bombs. Captain Bennion was mortally wounded when hit in the stomach by shrapnel while on the command bridge. Other crew members tried to move him to a safer location, but he refused, He continued directing his crew while holding his wound closed with one hand until he died of blood loss two hours later. His Medal of Honor Citation read:

"For conspicuous devotion to duty, extraordinary courage, and complete disregard of his own life, above and beyond the call of duty, during the attack on the Fleet at Pearl Harbor, by Japanese forces on 7 December 1941. As Commanding Officer of the U.S.S. West Virginia, after being mortally wounded, Captain Bennion evidenced apparent concern only in fighting and saving his ship, and strongly protested against being carried from the bridge."

As a 54-year-old Navy Captain, he was older and of higher rank than most WWII casualties. One of the sailors who tried to convince him to get medical attention was Cook Third Class Doris “Dorie” Miller, who manned anti-aircraft guns during the attack despite having no training on them. He was awarded the Navy Cross, second only to the Medal of Honor, becoming the first African-American to earn that award. He was killed in action two years later.

Captain Bennion was born May 5, 1887 in Vernon, Utah, a small farming community in Tooele County about 60 miles southwest of Salt Lake City. His family had a long history as devout members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS). His grandfather, John Bennion, was from Wales, joined the church in Liverpool, came to America, and trekked to Utah with the LDS pioneers in 1847.

Captain Bennion’s father, Israel Bennion, was a storekeeper and cattle rancher, and was prominent in the Vernon community as both a businessman and church leader. Mervyn’s mother, Jeannette Sharp Bennion, was born in Salt Lake City and was the daughter of Scottish immigrants. Mervyn was their second child and oldest son of nine children. His mother passed away in 1938 and his father in 1944.

He went to the lower grades in a log schoolhouse in Vernon, and when he reached his teen years went to a high school operated by the LDS church in Salt Lake City, where he lived with relatives. An excellent student, he passed the entrance exams for the Naval Academy and received his admission notice while working on an uncle’s ranch. He graduated from Annapolis third in his class in 1910.

After graduating from Annapolis, he held a variety of Navy assignments, both domestic and overseas, commanded several ships and served a stint in the Ordnance Bureau at Navy Yard in Washington, DC, during World War I. He assumed command of the West Virginia on July 1, 1941.

Throughout his Navy career he remained active in the LDS church. The night before the attack on Pearl Harbor, he had dinner at the home of Ralph Woolley, president of the Oahu Stake of the church, and he had planned to attend services there the next morning.

His younger brother, Howard Sharp Bennion, went to the United States Military Academy at West Point and graduated first in the class of 1912. He served as an engineer officer during World War I and was awarded the Distinguished Service Medal. Howard wrote an extensive biographical sketch of his brother that can be found at https://www.usswestvirginia.org/stories/story.php?id=10.

Howard chronicled how Mervyn learned hard work and discipline while growing up. He wrote the following about their father giving up his store for the daunting task of developing a cattle ranch on a homestead named Ben Lomond in the dry, sagebrush land near the West Tintic Mountains:

“As the oldest son of the family, many responsibilities were loaded on Mervyn’s shoulders. The first year, when he was nine, he was driving a partly broken, three-horse team, dragging a heavy harrow with a contrivance to enable him to dump the harrow and free it of the sagebrush it gathered. These hard years developed the qualities of endurance and sustained application in the face of heavy tasks, of resourcefulness and of assuming responsibilities. Many others have faced hard work, but few in his generation labored so hard with such little equipment to wrest a home from dry, unyielding ground.”

His father also helped pioneer dry-land wheat farming in the area south of Vernon and helped start a town there named Benmore, a combination of Bennion and Skidmore.

While serving in Washington, DC, Captain Bennion met Louise Clark, eldest daughter of Mr. and Mrs. J. Reuben Clark, Jr. They were married February 5, 1920, in the home of her parents in New York. Later, when Mervyn could get leave, their marriage was sealed in the Salt Lake City Temple. They had one son, Mervyn, Jr., who was born in 1925, served a few years in the Navy beginning in 1943, had a civilian career in Salt Lake City, and died in 2003. The children and grandchildren of Mervyn, Jr., carry on the family name.

The Navy honored Captain Bennion by naming a destroyer the USS Bennion. It was commissioned July 4, 1943, and his widow christened the ship when it was launched in Boston. American Legion posts in Salt Lake City and Honolulu were named for him. On the 10th anniversary of Pearl Harbor, the post in Salt Lake held a memorial service and placed a wreath on his grave, and the post in Hawaii dropped a wreath on the site of the attack.

His memory is honored in several ways in his home state. A plaque in his honor was unveiled in October 1947 at the Navy ROTC building at the University of Utah. On the 75th anniversary of Pearl Harbor in 2016, the State of Utah named the Central Utah Veterans Home in Payson for him. The Salt Lake City unit of the United States Naval Sea Cadets Corps is named Training Ship Mervyn S. Bennion.

He was initially buried in Hawaii, and his remains were returned to the States after the war and interred at the Salt Lake City Cemetery in October 1947. At his funeral, one of his Annapolis classmates, Captain Walter E. Brown, read Captain Bennion’s Medal of Honor citation. The prayer was offered by Ezra T. Benson, an LDS apostle who went on to become President of the church from 1985 until his death in 1994.

Captain Bennion’s name is inscribed along with four other Medal of Honor recipients from Utah on a marker at the Memory Grove Memorial in Salt Lake City. His widow passed away at age 98 on September 23, 1997, and his last surviving sibling died in 1972.

After being sunk at Pearl Harbor, the USS West Virginia was raised, refurbished in 1943-44, and saw service in the Philippine Campaign and the post-war occupation of Japan. She was decommissioned in 1947 and dismantled in 1959. One of her anti-aircraft guns is on display in City Park in Parkersburg, West Virginia, and the ship's wheel and binnacle are on display at the Hampton Roads Naval Museum. The mast is displayed in a plaza outside Oglebay Hall on the campus of West Virginia University, and the ship's bell is on display at the West Virginia State Museum in Charleston. Interstate Highway 470 in West Virginia is named the USS West Virginia Memorial Highway.

His brother Howard summed up Captain Bennion’s character as follows in the preface to his book:

“This sketch of the life of Mervyn Sharp Bennion, late Captain United States Navy, who died a glorious death at Pearl Harbor, December 7, 1941, in command of the battleship USS West Virginia, is written to help preserve to his family and friends the memory of the character, spirit, aims and deeds of this noble, inspiring and praiseworthy officer. . . . His own work and accomplishments seemed unimpressive to him: Even his heroic death, had he been here to tell it, would have been dismissed with scant reference to himself but full regard for the brave conduct and deeds of others. His long naval record was flawless and therefore brief and laconic - eloquent testimony of excellent conduct and splendid performance from beginning to end. His church record was one of unobtrusive, conscientious devotion to every duty.

Back of his actions in life and death was a great soul, the presence of which strongly affected those who came to know him, At Pearl Harbor it was his stout heart and cheerful spirit, as his life slowly ebbed away high up on the bridge of his stricken ship that gripped the hearts of his officers and men and thrilled and inspired the whole fleet, It is with his character and attributes that this sketch will primarily deal, For lack of knowledge I shall perforce deal sparingly with his work, I knew best his spirit and his character. He was and is my life leader, one to whom I am bound with the strongest ties of respect and affection.”

This story is part of the Stories Behind the Stars project (see www.storiesbehindthestars.org). This is a national effort of volunteers to write the stories of all 400,000+ of the US WWII fallen on Fold3 and Together We Served. Can you help write these stories? Related to this, there will be a smart phone app that will allow people to visit any war memorial or cemetery, scan the fallen's name and read his/her story.

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/91156064/mervyn-sharp-bennion

https://www.usswestvirginia.org/stories/story.php?id=10

https://www.thechurchnews.com/archives/1991-12-07/lds-captain-was-pearl-harbor-hero-145655

https://www.cmohs.org/recipients/mervyn-s-bennion

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_West_Virginia_(BB-48)#Postwar

https://tinyurl.com/y4ekwhn2

The History of the Samuel Bennion Biography

by Julie Bennion Mertlich

Helen Madsen

I first met Helen Madsen at a Bennion family reunion when I was a teenager. Reluctantly, I had gotten into the car along with my siblings as we drove from Idaho Falls to a stake center somewhere in Taylorsville, Utah. Tables of the cultural hall were covered with family memorabilia, including a bell from the USS Bennion, which was commissioned after Mervyn S. Bennion’s heroic actions during the bombing of Pearl Harbor. Lowell Bennion, author and educator, gave a talk about the Bennion family. Then a soft-spoken woman took the microphone. She explained the contents of the bulging manilla folder we were all to take home—family group sheets and pedigree charts, genealogy. I took one with Helen Madsen’s name stamped in the upper left-hand corner. I was 17, starting my senior year in high school, filled with thoughts far-removed from the dreaded word genealogy.

I graduated from high school then went on to college. Eventually I got my degree, married and began a family, but those seemingly innocuous manilla envelopes found their way into cardboard boxes every time I moved. As life marched on, I learned that a book was to be written about the life of my second great grandfather and 1847 pioneer, Samuel Bennion. Years passed and the book was not forthcoming. By then I had become engaged with family history. I have always kept a journal, and my patriarchal blessing reads, “You will be able to search out the names of deceased ancestors and put them in their proper family relationships and have their work done in the temple. I promise you that you will be successful in genealogy and find many, many of your family’s names that were thought to be lost. This will bring you great joy.” I have inherited from my Nana Lorilla Horne Bennion her dolls, her traveling case, a coat, silver pitchers, and other serving pieces. I know how to take care of them in acid free boxes. When I saw notices in the “Bennion Family Recorder,” I donated money to the writing of the Samuel Bennion book, thinking that it would be good to have one for Samuel as well as what we have for John.

But the book wasn’t forthcoming. After many years, the spirit worked on me and I started asking questions. I felt prompted to contact the Bennion family’s consummate genealogist, Helen Madsen, and we set up a meeting time. On the appointed day, I found myself on the porch of her home in West Valley, Utah. As she opened the screen door, she looked like she could have stepped out of the Hawarden  (pronounced, Harden) Wales Post office. She was diminutive in size, and I recognized her immediately as the soft-spoken women I had seen years ago. I first noticed her sparkling eyes with her gray hair pulled back framing a gentle smile. I introduced myself and asked what I could do to help. With that we began our years-long, mutual journey to complete the Samuel book.

She told me that a room in her basement had been converted for her research. Following this frail woman, worried she might fall, I made my way slowly down the steep linoleum stairs into a catacomb of boxes stacked upon boxes. To say the least, the sight was overwhelming to me as an amateur genealogist. Walls were covered in maps and diagrams. Every flat surface, including the floor underneath every table, was stacked with files or boxes. Dust covered everything. There was hardly any place to sit except for Helen’s chair at her computer. Several rolls of yellowed paper the size of butcher paper but lighter in weight were rolled upright in a corner, covered with handwritten family names. The only closet door was open with reams of paper likely from the last office supply store sale. Helen found me a metal chair and her story unfolded like another scroll. I was mesmerized.

Helen had traveled to Hawarden, Wales, several times gathering information for the work, diligently keeping records of people she met and detailed notes of significant locations. Returning home, she followed up on her new discoveries, waking early before her six children woke. She pursued interesting facts and researched stories of the life of the ancestors she loved so much. In 2011 she emailed me:

Somewhere in my teens I realized that there always seemed to be an “aunt” in each family who “did all the genealogy” and I determined that I would NOT be that aunt. And that was my thinking through my teenage years. It was not until the 1970’s when a series of events happened to sort of change my thinking. Circumstances occurred that frustrated me greatly. Uncle Ira had a Bennion Family meeting at his home. I remember Jerry Bennion was there, myself and Uncle Ira. One thing that really bothered me was that there had been books written about the two Bennion brother’s but no one knew anything about the sisters. In my youth I had occasionally wondered if I still had relatives walking around on the other side of the world. As a result of that meeting, and my determination to see what happened to the sisters, my desire to not be THAT aunt seemed to disappear and I concentrated on doing genealogy. I found I didn’t really know how. After frustrating attempts the opportunity for a scholarship at BYU Salt Lake in genealogy appeared. I took it and went nights and studied at 5:00 in the morning while the children were still sleeping. It took me about 10 years to obtain the degree.

She started this work before computers, back before genealogy was correlated when each person had their own nine-by-fifteen-inch Book of Remembrance with hand-written entries. Eventually the Personal Ancestral File (PAF) program came along, with every person asked to add four generations of their family to the record in the Church genealogy library. News stories came of a very large storage facility being built in Cottonwood Canyon where millions of records would be stored in a temperature-controlled environment. The progression continued from floppy disks to RAM, but Helen was never intimidated. Instead, she adapted to all these innovations, even thrived with them. She embraced the far-reaching computer and the power of its capacity. Later, a summer project was scanning all of Helen’s records—it accounted for more than a terabyte of information.

Still, many obstacles arose. She fell off her treadmill and got a black eye and she got pneumonia. After a flood in the basement of her home and due to her advancing age, she moved in with her son Ron near the South Jorden temple. Helen’s family had moved her genealogical material, including boxes of papers and her terabyte of electronic files, into Ron’s basement and a small bedroom just off the entrance. I sat on a three-legged stool while Helen worked at her PC; the work was slow gathering the necessary information for the Samuel book.

As I continued to visit her, I could see that age and energy was beginning to take its toll. Two hours was about as long as I could be there, but that length of time was also the limit of her stamina—when she tired and her voice became raspy and dry. Once she fell and hurt her wrist, but insisted that it wouldn’t slow her down. Still, she had slowed down, and searching through the files on her desktop to find her drafts of the Samuel book often took most of our time.

At the close of one of our sessions I asked her what drove her to do this research. She said her Patriarchal Blessing, similar to my own, says that she would be given the blessing of doing genealogy work. I then asked her what blessings she thinks she has received from doing this work? That “genealogy aunt” had a twinkle in her eye, and responded with the joy of knowing that the temple work was done.

When it became clear we needed help, the Bennion Family Organization hired Ron Clifford, but after completing two chapters, he had a heart attack. John S. Bennion, who teaches English at BYU, made contact with one of his former graduate students, Liz Knight, who finished the remaining chapters. Even after that, Helen wanted to go through the book line-by-line on her ancient computer. Every time we made a change the whole program broke down, and we had to call her son, Mark Madsen, for help with getting things running again. Then my husband, Ross Mertlich, became ill with cancer, and I couldn’t spend much time with Helen anymore.

In the meantime, John E. Bennion, president of the Bennion Family Association, went on a mission, and the family organization went into cold storage. Recently it has been revived, and the board of the Association authorized money to finish the book. John S. Bennion and Katherine Richards have helped me get the book ready for printing—editing the text and laying it out with pictures.

Gorden B. Hinckley said, “Be true to who you are and the family name that you bear.” No one lived that more fully than Helen Madsen. Through the years when I left her house after one of our sessions, I felt like I’d been on sacred ground. She spent her life getting this book ready. Often it felt like unseen others were there. Despite the challenges and roadblocks, I know God helped move this work along. As a people, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints do what we can with genealogy, but we are helped along the way. I feel that Samuel, Mary, Rhoda, and Helen are all happy that this book is finally coming out.

Bennion Family Recorder